HAP Analysis: Archive docs and create implementation action plan

- Archive all existing markdown documentation files - Create comprehensive HAP_ACTION_PLAN.md with: * Analysis of current BZZZ implementation vs HAP vision * 4-phase implementation strategy * Structural reorganization approach (multi-binary) * HAP interface implementation roadmap - Preserve existing functionality while adding human agent portal - Focus on incremental migration over rewrite 🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.ai/code) Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
2025-08-29 14:10:13 +10:00
parent 92779523c0
commit ec81dc9ddc
25 changed files with 368 additions and 48 deletions
--- a/archive/PROJECT_TODOS.md
+++ b/archive/PROJECT_TODOS.md
@@ -0,0 +1,264 @@
+# BZZZ P2P Coordination System - TODO List
+
+---
+
+## 🎯 **PHASE 1 UCXL INTEGRATION - COMPLETED ✅** 
+**Status**: Successfully implemented and tested (2025-08-07)
+
+### ✅ **UCXL Protocol Foundation (BZZZ)**
+**Branch**: `feature/ucxl-protocol-integration`
+- ✅ Complete UCXL address parser with BNF grammar validation
+- ✅ Temporal navigation system (`~~`, `^^`, `*^`, `*~`) with bounds checking  
+- ✅ UCXI HTTP server with REST-like operations (GET/PUT/POST/DELETE/ANNOUNCE)
+- ✅ 87 comprehensive tests all passing
+- ✅ Production-ready integration with existing P2P architecture (**opt-in via config**)
+- ✅ Semantic addressing with wildcards and version control support
+
+**Key Files**: `pkg/ucxl/address.go`, `pkg/ucxl/temporal.go`, `pkg/ucxi/server.go`, `pkg/ucxi/resolver.go`
+
+### ✅ **SLURP Decision Ingestion System** 
+**Branch**: `feature/ucxl-decision-ingestion`
+- ✅ Complete decision node schema with UCXL address validation
+- ✅ Citation chain validation with circular reference prevention  
+- ✅ Bounded reasoning with configurable depth limits (not temporal windows)
+- ✅ Async decision ingestion pipeline with priority queuing
+- ✅ Graph database integration for global context graph building
+- ✅ Semantic search with embedding-based similarity matching
+
+**Key Files**: `ucxl_decisions.py`, `decisions.py`, `decision_*_service.py`, PostgreSQL schema
+
+### 🔄 **IMPORTANT: EXISTING FUNCTIONALITY PRESERVED**
+```
+✅ GitHub Issues → BZZZ Agents → Task Execution → Pull Requests (UNCHANGED)
+                        ↓ (optional, when UCXL.Enabled=true)
+✅ UCXL Decision Publishing → SLURP → Global Context Graph (NEW)
+```
+
+---
+
+## 🚀 **NEXT PRIORITIES - PHASE 2 UCXL ENHANCEMENT**
+
+### **P2P DHT Integration for UCXL (High Priority)**
+- [ ] Implement distributed UCXL address resolution across cluster
+- [ ] Add UCXL content announcement and discovery via DHT  
+- [ ] Integrate with existing mDNS discovery system
+- [ ] Add content routing and replication for high availability
+
+### **Decision Publishing Integration (High Priority)**
+- [ ] Connect BZZZ task completion to SLURP decision publishing
+- [ ] Add decision worthiness heuristics (filter ephemeral vs. meaningful decisions)
+- [ ] Implement structured decision node creation after task execution
+- [ ] Add citation linking to existing context and justifications
+
+### **OpenAI GPT-4 + MCP Integration (High Priority)**  
+- [ ] Create MCP tools for UCXL operations (bzzz_announce, bzzz_lookup, bzzz_get, etc.)
+- [ ] Implement GPT-4 agent framework for advanced reasoning
+- [ ] Add cost tracking and rate limiting for OpenAI API calls (key stored in secrets)
+- [ ] Enable multi-agent collaboration via UCXL addressing
+
+---
+
+## 📋 **ORIGINAL PRIORITIES REMAIN ACTIVE**
+
+## Highest Priority - RL Context Curator Integration
+
+### 0. RL Context Curator Integration Tasks
+**Priority: Critical - Integration with HCFS RL Context Curator**
+- [ ] **Feedback Event Publishing System**
+  - [ ] Extend `pubsub/pubsub.go` to handle `feedback_event` message types
+  - [ ] Add context feedback schema validation
+  - [ ] Implement feedback event routing to RL Context Curator
+  - [ ] Add support for upvote, downvote, forgetfulness, task_success, task_failure events
+
+- [ ] **Hypercore Logging Integration** 
+  - [ ] Modify `logging/hypercore.go` to log context relevance feedback
+  - [ ] Add feedback event schema to hypercore logs for RL training data
+  - [ ] Implement context usage tracking for learning signals
+  - [ ] Add agent role and directory scope to logged events
+
+- [ ] **P2P Context Feedback Routing**
+  - [ ] Extend `p2p/node.go` to route context feedback messages
+  - [ ] Add dedicated P2P topic for feedback events: `bzzz/context-feedback/v1`
+  - [ ] Ensure feedback events reach RL Context Curator across P2P network
+  - [ ] Implement feedback message deduplication and ordering
+
+- [ ] **Agent Role and Directory Scope Configuration**
+  - [ ] Create new file `agent/role_config.go` for role definitions
+  - [ ] Implement role-based agent configuration (backend, frontend, devops, qa)
+  - [ ] Add directory scope patterns for each agent role
+  - [ ] Support dynamic role assignment and capability updates
+  - [ ] Integrate with existing agent capability broadcasting
+
+- [ ] **Context Feedback Collection Triggers**
+  - [ ] Add hooks in task completion workflows to trigger feedback collection
+  - [ ] Implement automatic feedback requests after successful task completions
+  - [ ] Add manual feedback collection endpoints for agents
+  - [ ] Create feedback confidence scoring based on task outcomes
+
+## High Priority - Immediate Blockers
+
+### 1. Local Git Hosting Solution
+**Priority: Critical**
+- [ ] **Deploy Local GitLab Instance**
+  - [ ] Configure GitLab Community Edition on Docker Swarm
+  - [ ] Set up domain/subdomain (e.g., `gitlab.bzzz.local` or `git.home.deepblack.cloud`)
+  - [ ] Configure SSL certificates via Traefik/Let's Encrypt
+  - [ ] Create test organization and repositories
+  - [ ] Import/create realistic project structures
+
+- [ ] **Alternative: Deploy Gitea Instance**
+  - [ ] Evaluate Gitea as lighter alternative to GitLab
+  - [ ] Docker Swarm deployment configuration
+  - [ ] Domain and SSL setup
+  - [ ] Test repository creation and API access
+
+- [ ] **Local Repository Setup**
+  - [ ] Create mock repositories that actually exist:
+    - `bzzz-coordination-platform` (simulating WHOOSH)
+    - `bzzz-p2p-system` (actual Bzzz codebase)
+    - `distributed-ai-development`
+    - `infrastructure-automation`
+  - [ ] Add realistic issues with `bzzz-task` labels
+  - [ ] Configure repository access tokens
+  - [ ] Test GitHub API compatibility
+
+### 2. Task Claim Logic Enhancement
+**Priority: Critical**
+- [ ] **Analyze Current Bzzz Binary Workflow**
+  - [ ] Map current task discovery process in bzzz binary
+  - [ ] Identify where task claiming should occur
+  - [ ] Document current P2P message flow
+
+- [ ] **Implement Active Task Discovery**
+  - [ ] Add periodic repository polling in bzzz agents
+  - [ ] Implement task evaluation and filtering logic
+  - [ ] Add task claiming attempts with conflict resolution
+
+- [ ] **Enhance Task Claim Logic in Go Code**
+  - [ ] Modify `github/integration.go` to actively claim suitable tasks
+  - [ ] Add retry logic for failed claims
+  - [ ] Implement task priority evaluation
+  - [ ] Add coordination messaging for task claims
+
+- [ ] **P2P Coordination for Task Claims**
+  - [ ] Implement distributed task claiming protocol
+  - [ ] Add conflict resolution when multiple agents claim same task
+  - [ ] Enhance availability broadcasting with claimed task status
+
+## Medium Priority - Core Functionality
+
+### 3. Agent Work Execution
+- [ ] **Complete Work Capture Integration**
+  - [ ] Modify bzzz agents to actually submit work to mock API endpoints
+  - [ ] Test prompt logging with Ollama models
+  - [ ] Verify meta-thinking tool utilization
+  - [ ] Capture actual code generation and pull request content
+
+- [ ] **Ollama Model Integration Testing**
+  - [ ] Verify agent prompts are reaching Ollama endpoints
+  - [ ] Test meta-thinking capabilities with local models
+  - [ ] Document model performance with coordination tasks
+  - [ ] Optimize prompt engineering for coordination scenarios
+
+### 4. Real Coordination Scenarios
+- [ ] **Cross-Repository Dependency Testing**
+  - [ ] Create realistic dependency scenarios between repositories
+  - [ ] Test antennae framework with actual dependency conflicts
+  - [ ] Verify coordination session creation and resolution
+
+- [ ] **Multi-Agent Task Coordination**
+  - [ ] Test scenarios with multiple agents working on related tasks
+  - [ ] Verify conflict detection and resolution
+  - [ ] Test consensus mechanisms
+
+### 5. Infrastructure Improvements
+- [ ] **Docker Overlay Network Issues**
+  - [ ] Debug connectivity issues between services
+  - [ ] Optimize network performance for coordination messages
+  - [ ] Ensure proper service discovery in swarm environment
+
+- [ ] **Enhanced Monitoring**
+  - [ ] Add metrics collection for coordination performance
+  - [ ] Implement alerting for coordination failures
+  - [ ] Create historical coordination analytics
+
+## Low Priority - Nice to Have
+
+### 6. User Interface Enhancements
+- [ ] **Web-Based Coordination Dashboard**
+  - [ ] Create web interface for monitoring coordination activity
+  - [ ] Add visual representation of P2P network topology
+  - [ ] Show task dependencies and coordination sessions
+
+- [ ] **Enhanced CLI Tools**
+  - [ ] Add bzzz CLI commands for manual task management
+  - [ ] Create debugging tools for coordination issues
+  - [ ] Add configuration management utilities
+
+### 7. Documentation and Testing
+- [ ] **Comprehensive Documentation**
+  - [ ] Document P2P coordination protocols
+  - [ ] Create deployment guides for new environments
+  - [ ] Add troubleshooting documentation
+
+- [ ] **Automated Testing Suite**
+  - [ ] Create integration tests for coordination scenarios
+  - [ ] Add performance benchmarks
+  - [ ] Implement continuous testing pipeline
+
+### 8. Advanced Features
+- [ ] **Dynamic Agent Capabilities**
+  - [ ] Allow agents to learn and adapt capabilities
+  - [ ] Implement capability evolution based on task history
+  - [ ] Add skill-based task routing
+
+- [ ] **Advanced Coordination Algorithms**
+  - [ ] Implement more sophisticated consensus mechanisms
+  - [ ] Add economic models for task allocation
+  - [ ] Create coordination learning from historical data
+
+## Technical Debt and Maintenance
+
+### 9. Code Quality Improvements
+- [ ] **Error Handling Enhancement**
+  - [ ] Improve error reporting in coordination failures
+  - [ ] Add graceful degradation for network issues
+  - [ ] Implement proper logging throughout the system
+
+- [ ] **Performance Optimization**
+  - [ ] Profile P2P message overhead
+  - [ ] Optimize database queries for task discovery
+  - [ ] Improve coordination session efficiency
+
+### 10. Security Enhancements
+- [ ] **Agent Authentication**
+  - [ ] Implement proper agent identity verification
+  - [ ] Add authorization for task claims
+  - [ ] Secure coordination message exchange
+
+- [ ] **Repository Access Security**
+  - [ ] Audit GitHub/Git access patterns
+  - [ ] Implement least-privilege access principles
+  - [ ] Add credential rotation mechanisms
+
+## Immediate Next Steps (This Week)
+
+1. **Deploy Local GitLab/Gitea** - Resolve repository access issues
+2. **Enhance Task Claim Logic** - Make agents actively discover and claim tasks
+3. **Test Real Coordination** - Verify agents actually perform work on local repositories
+4. **Debug Network Issues** - Ensure all components communicate properly
+
+## Dependencies and Blockers
+
+- **Local Git Hosting**: Blocks real task testing and agent work verification
+- **Task Claim Logic**: Blocks agent activation and coordination testing
+- **Network Issues**: May impact agent communication and coordination
+
+## Success Metrics
+
+- [ ] Agents successfully discover and claim tasks from local repositories
+- [ ] Real code generation and pull request creation captured
+- [ ] Cross-repository coordination sessions functioning
+- [ ] Multiple agents coordinating on dependent tasks
+- [ ] Ollama models successfully utilized for meta-thinking
+- [ ] Performance metrics showing sub-second coordination response times