HCFS/PROJECT_PART_3.md

You're absolutely on point considering Temporal Graph Networks (TGNs) as a mechanism to maintain coherence in your HCFS DB as context evolves. These models are explicitly designed for time-evolving graph data—perfect for tracking nodes (e.g., paths or context blobs) and edges (e.g. inheritance, version links) over time.

---

🧠 1. Temporal Graph Networks (TGNs) — an ideal fit for evolving context

• TGN architecture processes a stream of time-stamped events (e.g. new context blob at path, version update, parent-child change) and updates node-level memory embeddings, allowing representation of each entity’s evolving state (arXiv, GitHub).
• These embeddings capture both structural and temporal dynamics—so your system can reason about past context versions, detect divergence, and flag incoherence across agents over time.

Other relevant models include:

• Know‑Evolve: modeling non-linear evolution of relationships over time as point processes benchmarked in knowledge graphs (arXiv, Proceedings of Machine Learning Research).
• EvolveGCN: uses an RNN to evolve GCN parameters rather than individual embeddings, helpful in link or version prediction scenarios (arXiv).

---

🎯 2. How temporal graph modeling applies to HCFS

Imagine your HCFS DB as a temporal knowledge graph:

• Nodes: context blobs, path nodes, agents
• Edges: version-of, parent-path, contributor-of, merge-from
• Timestamps on each event (e.g. blob creation/update, merge operation)

A TGN can ingest an event stream like:

(t₁) blob₁ created at /project/x, version=1  
(t₂) blob₂ created at same path, version=2 (parent blob₁)  
(t₃) agent A publishes blob₃ at /project/x  
(t₄) merge blob₂, blob₃ => blob₄  
...

As events flow in, TGN updates embeddings per node. Downstream you can:

• Detect drifts or divergence across path histories
• Cluster similar changes and summarize coherent updates
• Predict coherence issues: e.g. if agents diverge, versus converge

---

📚 Peer-Reviewed Foundations

• Temporal GNN survey outlines formal settings, tasks, and taxonomy for TGNNs, helping in understanding processing models, discretization, and evaluation frameworks (arXiv, arXiv).
• Dynamic Neighborhood Selection (CATGNN) handles evolving neighborhood interactions via memory modules—analogous to how sibling path nodes or contributors change over time (SpringerLink).
• The broader literature on temporal knowledge graphs and reasoning frameworks (e.g., EvoKG, WGP‑NN) reinforce that modeling both event timing and structure is essential for accurate prediction and anomaly detection (arXiv, arXiv).

---

🧩 Integration Options for HCFS

Option A: Lightweight TGN-based coherence monitor

• Build your versioned graph model (relational or graph DB)
• Hook in an incremental TGN (e.g. using Twitter TGN or PyTorch Geometric Temporal)
• Train a lightweight task: detect divergence or context drift across paths

Option B: Embedded temporal embedding layer

• Couple TGN-style memory modules with context retrieval
• When context is fetched for (path, depth=N), combine static inherited blobs and dynamic embedding summarizers for coherence-aware top-k suggestions
• Enables agents to get both content and confidence signals

---

✅ Summary Table

Use Case	Model	Benefit
Evolving context tracking	TGN with node-memory	captures time-series history of path and blob changes
Predicting coherence issues	Know-Evolve or EvoKG models	anticipate divergence before agents conflict
Summarization & relevance ranking	CATGNN style selection	focus context retrieval on recent or critical updates
Hybrid relational/graph DB	Graph topology + timestamps	supports both hierarchy and version/time semantics

---

🚀 Next Steps

1. Define your graph event schema (blob creation, merge, parent change).
2. Select a framework: e.g. Twitter’s TGN library (GitHub) or PyTorch Geometric Temporal.
3. Train simple prediction tasks: e.g. coherence anomalies, version conflicts.
4. Use learned embeddings as features in context relevance ranking or ambiguity detection.

Absolutely—PyTorch Geometric Temporal (PyG-T) is a great starting point for modeling how permission changes cascade context shifts in your HCFS. Let’s map that out:

---

🔁 1. Graph + Permissions + Temporal Events

Imagine your HCFS as a temporal graph where:

• Nodes represent paths, context blobs, and agent identities.
• Edges model relationships: parent-path, version-of, and permission-grant (e.g. agent-to-path).
• Each change (e.g. permission granted/revoked, context blob added/updated) emits an event: (src_node, dst_node, event_type, timestamp)—fit for PyG-T's TemporalData structure (PyG Documentation).

Example events:

(agentA → path /submodule): PERMISSION_GRANTED at t1  
(path /submodule): CONTEXT_UPDATED by agentA at t2  
(agentA → path): PERMISSION_REVOKED at t3

---

🧠 2. Use Case: Permission Cascades → Context Exposure Changes

Scenario:

• Submodule /modX changes permissions: agent A loses read access at time t3.
• That revocation should trigger a context cascade: any context blobs previously created by agent A for /modX are no longer visible to A or its group, and any derived context (e.g. merged summaries) may need invalidation or regeneration.

TGN Role:

• A Temporal Graph Neural Network can learn and flag such cascades. By training on sequences of permission-change events and context-access events, your model can predict which context blobs become stale or inaccessible due to new permission states.

---

⚙️ 3. Implementation Sketch with PyTorch Geometric Temporal

A. Event Stream Construction

Use PyG-T’s TemporalData API to build your dataset:

from torch_geometric.data import TemporalData
events = TemporalData(
    src=torch.tensor([...]),  # source node IDs
    dst=torch.tensor([...]),  # destination node IDs
    t=torch.tensor([...]),    # timestamps
    msg=torch.tensor([...])   # event types encoded
)

Event types encode changes: PERMISSION_GRANTED, REVOKE, CONTEXT_UPDATE, MERGE, etc. (PyG Documentation)

B. Model Choice

• Use recurrent layers like GConvGRU or GConvLSTM to process evolving structure and events. This allows the model to remember prior permission relationships and context updates. (PyTorch Forums, PyTorch Forums)

C. Training Task

• Label context exposure windows correctly: whether agent had valid permission at query time.
• Train to predict: (a) contexts that must be invalidated upon a permission revocation, (b) agents likely to be impacted by a permission change.

You can also forecast which agents will be affected by future cascading permission changes.

---

👁️ 4. Operational Integration

Monitoring Pipeline:

1. Every permission or context change emits an event into your temporal graph.

2. TGN model continuously ingests event stream, updating node embeddings.

3. Agent requests for context trigger a check:

   • Is the agent’s embedding synchronized with the latest permission state?
   • Does the model flag outdated or stale blobs needing recompute?

Coherence Actions:

• On permission cascade, generate tasks to:

  • Invalidate or reassign context blobs,
  • Regenerate summaries for authorized agents,
  • Notify subscribed agents of access revocation.

---

📊 Summary Table

Component	Description
Event stream	Captures permission and context changes as timestamped edges/nodes in a TemporalData graph
Dynamic permission node	Connection between agent and path nodes representing access rights
TGN model	Processes events to update node embedding states over time
Training objective	Predict context invalidation needs and agents affected by permission shifts
Run-time check	On context fetch, ensure embedding reflects current permissions; flag stale data

---

📚 Supporting References

• PyTorch Geometric Temporal’s TemporalData API handles event-based temporal graphs elegantly for this use case (PyG Documentation).
• Discussions of node-feature input shapes and recurrent temporal GNNs (GConvGRU, GConvLSTM) show how to structure the learning model (PyTorch Forums, PyTorch Forums).
• Relationship-based access control (ReBAC) aligns with modeling permissions as graph relationships between agents and resources (Wikipedia).

---

🚀 Next Steps:

1. Define node and edge IDs: assign IDs to agents, paths, and context blobs.
2. Build event collector to log permission and context operations with timestamps.
3. Construct TemporalData sequences for model ingestion.
4. Prototype a TGN using PyG-T, train on synthetic cascades (grant → context update → revoke).
5. Validate cascade detection and context invalidation effectiveness.